Why Can’t MLS NEXT Players Play High School?

MLS NEXT’s policy restricting players from participating in high school soccer has sparked tons of discussion within the U.S. youth soccer community. Just read the many forums!

As a parent of an MLS NEXT player and a close observer, I’ve seen the impact this rule can have on young athletes and their families.

The rule strengthens MLS NEXT by retaining players within its ecosystem but deprives high schools of top soccer talent.

Why does the policy exist and what effect does it have? I’m here to address this.

The Policy and Its Rationale

MLS NEXT’s official stance is clear: “MLS NEXT players are not permitted to play high school soccer.” This policy aims to:

1. Maintain a consistent, high-level training environment year-round
2. Reduce injury risks from overplaying
3. Ensure exposure to top-tier coaching and competition

While these goals are admirable, they sometimes overlook the intangible benefits of high school sports.

There’s something about playing for your school. The pride and feeling like you belong to a community is so healthy. This is missing for many boys.

Implications and Considerations

While the focus on player development is there, it has raised several concerns:

• Community Impact: High school soccer often plays a vital role in school spirit and local pride. I’ve seen how school sports can bring a community together and make an impact on a young athlete.
• Player Choices: Young athletes must make difficult decisions between pursuing elite pathways and participating in traditional school experiences. I can attest to the emotional toll this choice often takes.
• Equity Issues: Exceptions for some private school students have led to discussions about fairness in implementation. Is it fair if it’s not the same across the board?

These three issues should give pause.

If a player wants to play for their school, they should.

If a player wants to play at the highest level in the youth soccer pyramid, they should.

Unfortunately, players who go to public school can’t have it both ways. Unless…

Recent Developments (Ability to Play HS)

As of January 2025, MLS NEXT has announced plans for a new competition tier that may allow some high school participation.

This development suggests a potential shift towards finding a balance between club and traditional soccer experiences.

From my perspective, this is a step in the right direction. You can read more about it here.

Looking Forward

The MLS NEXT policy presents a complex dilemma in youth soccer development.

While it strengthens the league and provides a focused pathway for elite players, it also comes at the cost of traditional high school experiences.

There’s no clear-cut “right” or “wrong” approach here, as both paths offer unique benefits.

However, if the goal is to compete on a global scale and elevate U.S. soccer to international prominence, the MLS NEXT pathway seems to be a step in the right direction.

Ultimately, the approach’s success hinges on balancing elite player development with maintaining youth engagement in the sport.